.png)
We live in South Florida and we get hurricanes and crazy winds, so we need to be protected. When it comes to protecting your home openings from hurricanes, the debate usually boils down to two options: hurricane screens vs shutters. Both have their merits, but as a company that has spent years in the South Florida market specializing in hurricane screens, I can tell you that there is one clear winner for the money. Modern hurricane screens are more than just a new alternative—they’re a smarter investment for your home.
Hurricane Screens: The Modern Solution
Let’s start with the basics: What exactly are hurricane screens? These aren’t your typical window screens that keep bugs out on a summer evening. Hurricane screens are heavy-duty, impact-resistant barriers woven with kevlar for strength and polyester for flexibility designed to protect your windows, doors, and outdoor spaces from flying debris during a storm. It's like having a bulletproof vest around your home's openings. And here’s the kicker—they do all this without blocking your view or turning your home into a dark cave.
Benefits of Hurricane Screens
Visibility and Light - One of the standout benefits of hurricane screens is that they allow you to see outside even when they’re deployed. You can enjoy natural light and keep an eye on what’s happening outside while still being protected. This is huge, especially if you’re someone who doesn’t want to feel boxed in during a storm.
Easy Installation and Operation - Hurricane screens, especially motorized ones, are incredibly easy to use. You can deploy them with the push of a button, and they retract just as easily when the storm passes. This is a major advantage over shutters, which can be a hassle to open and close, especially in a hurry.
Versatility - Here’s a pro tip: Hurricane screens can do more than just protect your home during a storm. Many of our clients use them year-round as insect screens or to provide shade on hot days. You’re getting a two-for-one deal, which is something you don’t get with shutters.
Impact Resistance- Let’s talk about strength. The best hurricane screens, like those from Progressive Screens and Fenetex, are designed to withstand impacts from debris flying at high speeds. These aren’t flimsy pieces of fabric—they’re tough, durable, and built to last. If you’re serious about protecting your home, this is a feature you can’t afford to overlook.
Shutters: The Traditional Choice
Now, let’s give shutters their due. They’ve been around forever and are still a popular choice for hurricane protection. But are they the best choice? Let’s dig into what they offer.
Benefits of Hurricane Shutters
DurabilityShutters are known for their durability. They’re built to withstand strong winds and impacts. They’re also a permanent fixture, meaning they’re always ready to go when a storm is on the horizon.
Aesthetic Options - One thing shutters have going for them is design options. They come in various styles—roll-down, accordion, Bahama, and colonial shutters—so you can find something that fits your home’s aesthetic. But remember, that style comes at a price, both in terms of money and convenience.
Added Security - Shutters offer a level of security that screens don’t, especially when it comes to protecting your home from break-ins. If security is a top concern, shutters might be worth considering.
Hurricane Screens vs Shutters: The Head-to-Head Comparison
Now that we’ve covered the basics, let’s get into the nitty-gritty of how hurricane screens stack up against shutters.
Cost
Initial Cost and Long-Term Value- Yes, manual shutters might seem cheaper upfront, but consider the long-term value. Hurricane screens, especially motorized ones, offer added functionality and convenience that shutters just can’t match. Plus, when you factor in the potential energy savings from using screens as shade, the cost difference starts to level out. If considering motorized shades, then its a pretty even comparison.
Ease of Use
Motorized Screens vs. Manual Shutters - Here’s where screens really shine. With motorized screens, you can protect your entire home with the push of a button. No ladders, no wrestling with heavy metal panels—just effortless protection. Shutters, especially non-motorized ones, require more effort. And if you’ve ever tried to close shutters in the middle of a storm, you know it’s not fun.
Aesthetics
Sleek and Modern vs. Classic and Traditional - If you’re going for a modern, sleek look, screens are the way to go. They blend seamlessly into your home’s design and don’t stand out when not in use. Shutters, on the other hand, are more traditional and can add a certain charm to your home. But let’s be honest—screens are less intrusive and offer more versatility.
Installation and Permitting: The Hidden Headache
Here’s something a lot of folks don’t think about until it’s too late: the installation process and the need for permits. Whether you’re installing screens or shutters, you might need to pull a permit, and that process is different in every municipality. PLAN AHEAD AND ORDER WITH TIME, PLEASE.
Permit Process: What to Expect
Dealing with Local Regulations - Permits are a necessary evil, but the process can vary widely depending on where you live. In some areas, getting a permit for hurricane screens is straightforward, but in others, it’s a bureaucratic nightmare. I’ve had clients in one city get their permit in a week, while another client just a few miles away was stuck waiting for months.
We have had many clients where we had the screens ready to go, but the local permitting office had other ideas. It took weeks of back-and-forth, plus a few extra inspections, just to get the green light. The lesson here? Know what you’re getting into before you start.
Real-Life Considerations: What’s Best for Your Home?
Choosing between hurricane screens and shutters isn’t just about the pros and cons—it’s about what works best for your specific situation.
Climate
High-Risk Areas- If you live in a high-risk area where hurricanes and high winds are a regular threat, the convenience and durability of hurricane screens make them the better choice. The ability to deploy them quickly and easily could make all the difference.
Home Design
Matching Your Home’s Style - If you have a modern home, screens are the obvious choice. They won’t detract from your home’s aesthetic and offer a level of protection that’s hard to beat. On the other hand, if you have a classic or colonial-style home, shutters might fit the look better—but that’s a style choice, not a practical one.
Longevity and Maintenance
Low Maintenance Wins the Race - Screens require less maintenance over time. With motorized options, there’s minimal upkeep beyond basic cleaning. Shutters, especially those made of wood, need regular care to prevent wear and tear.
Which One Is Right for You?
At the end of the day, the choice between hurricane screens and shutters comes down to your personal needs, style preferences, and the specific demands of your home.
My Recommendation - As someone who has seen these products in action for years, I’m a big believer in hurricane screens. They offer a modern, versatile solution that fits today’s lifestyle. The ease of use, combined with their strength and durability, makes them the better investment for most homeowners. If you want something that’s not only functional but also enhances your home’s look and feel, screens are the way to go.
Make the Smart Choice
Whether you choose screens or shutters, the most important thing is to protect your home. But if you’re looking for the best combination of convenience, strength, and modern appeal, hurricane screens are the clear winner. Don’t wait until the next storm is on the horizon—take action now and invest in the best protection for your home. If you need more guidance, feel free to reach out. I’m here to help you make the best choice for your home and your family’s safety.
Comments